Introduction: By Fire, By Water depicts the end of an eight-hundred year era in Spain, the era known as convivencia. It may be helpful, as background, to see all that was achieved during that era, and to get a sense for all that Spain lost (as well as what she gained) through the process of “unification.”
THE CONVIVENCIA IN MEDIEVAL SPAIN — A TIMELINE
The term convivencia (“coexistence”) refers to the period when Christians, Jews, and Muslims shared rulership of the Iberian Peninsula. This period was one of the most fruitful and significant in European cultural history. However, forces of intolerance, blame, and superstition continued to vie against the forces that promoted cultural exchange and expansion. Major dates include:
![]() |
Synagogue, Toledo creativecommons.org |
711 Islamic Berbers and Arabs (the “Moors”) invade Spain from North Africa. The caliphate they create is far more tolerant than the Christian Visigoth society they conquer.
10th and 11th centuries Cordova and Toledo are the most prominent and sophisticated cities in Europe, producing important scholars, poets, scientists, merchants, and philosophers. Islamic-Spanish architecture, harmonizing complex geometries, reaches its zenith. An extraordinary example of cross-cultural literary wealth, the poetic form called muwashaha, calls for both Latin and Classical Arabic versification within the same poem.
1066 The crucifixion of the Jewish vizier of Granada, and the subsequent massacre of Jews throughout Granada, mark the beginning of the end of the Golden Age of Judaism in Spain.
12th century The Muslim Averroes and the Jewish Maimonides reintroduce Aristotelian reasoning to Europe, foreshadowing Aquinas and ultimately the Renaissance.
1118 Alfonso I of Aragon reconquers Saragossa and its stunning fortresscastle, the Aljaferia, future home of King Ferdinand.
10th and 11th centuries Cordova and Toledo are the most prominent and sophisticated cities in Europe, producing important scholars, poets, scientists, merchants, and philosophers. Islamic-Spanish architecture, harmonizing complex geometries, reaches its zenith. An extraordinary example of cross-cultural literary wealth, the poetic form called muwashaha, calls for both Latin and Classical Arabic versification within the same poem.
1066 The crucifixion of the Jewish vizier of Granada, and the subsequent massacre of Jews throughout Granada, mark the beginning of the end of the Golden Age of Judaism in Spain.
12th century The Muslim Averroes and the Jewish Maimonides reintroduce Aristotelian reasoning to Europe, foreshadowing Aquinas and ultimately the Renaissance.
1118 Alfonso I of Aragon reconquers Saragossa and its stunning fortresscastle, the Aljaferia, future home of King Ferdinand.
![]() |
Aljaferia Palaca, Saragossa creativecommons.org |
13th century The Islamic presence in Spain, under pressure from Christian forces, retreats to the Emirate of Granada, at the southern tip of the Iberian Peninsula.
1236 Ferdinand III of Castile reconquers Cordova.
Late 14th century Anti-Jewish riots throughout Christian Spain lead to forced conversions and deaths.
Late 15th century By the late fifteenth century, the end of convivencia is in sight as Spain retreats into a tragic, monolithic parody of its imagined past. The events listed below, as witnessed by Luis de Santángel, the chancellor of Aragon, form the historical background of By Fire, By Water:
October 19, 1469 Marriage of Ferdinand II of Aragon and Isabella of Castile.
September 15, 1485 Murder of Pedro de Arbues, first chief inquisitor of the kingdom of Aragon.
August 18, 1487 Auto-da-fé (religious trial) in Saragossa, the capital of Aragon, including members of the chancellor’s family.
January 2, 1492 Fall of the Emirate of Granada, the last Islamic political entity in Western Europe.
March 31, 1492 Expulsion Edict, aka the Alhambra Decree, ordering all Jews to depart from Spain, leaving their wealth and possessions behind.
July 31, 1492 Final date for all Jews to quit Spain.
August 3, 1492 Christopher Columbus’s ships depart on a voyage of discovery.
October 12, 1492 Columbus lands in the present-day Bahamas.
1236 Ferdinand III of Castile reconquers Cordova.
Late 14th century Anti-Jewish riots throughout Christian Spain lead to forced conversions and deaths.
Late 15th century By the late fifteenth century, the end of convivencia is in sight as Spain retreats into a tragic, monolithic parody of its imagined past. The events listed below, as witnessed by Luis de Santángel, the chancellor of Aragon, form the historical background of By Fire, By Water:
October 19, 1469 Marriage of Ferdinand II of Aragon and Isabella of Castile.
September 15, 1485 Murder of Pedro de Arbues, first chief inquisitor of the kingdom of Aragon.
August 18, 1487 Auto-da-fé (religious trial) in Saragossa, the capital of Aragon, including members of the chancellor’s family.
January 2, 1492 Fall of the Emirate of Granada, the last Islamic political entity in Western Europe.
March 31, 1492 Expulsion Edict, aka the Alhambra Decree, ordering all Jews to depart from Spain, leaving their wealth and possessions behind.
July 31, 1492 Final date for all Jews to quit Spain.
August 3, 1492 Christopher Columbus’s ships depart on a voyage of discovery.
October 12, 1492 Columbus lands in the present-day Bahamas.
![]() |
Columbus at the Royal Court of Spain by V. Brozik 1884 |
Thank you to Mitchell for stopping by and writing such an interesting post!!! And now on to the giveaway, of which PTTP has been given FIVE copies of By Fire, By Water to giveaway!

Within the dramatic story lies a subtle, insightful examination of the crisis of faith at the heart of the Spanish Inquisition. Irresolvable conflict rages within the conversos in By Fire, By Water, torn between the religion they left behind and the conversion meant to ensure their safety. In this story of love, God, faith, and torture, fifteenth-century Spain comes to dazzling, engrossing life.
EEP! I would LOVE to win this book! It's on my TBR!
ReplyDeleteamberr610[at]gmail[dot]com
Sounds great...would love to read. Thanks!
ReplyDeleteCourtney
Stilettostorytime(at)gmail(dot)com
Ooh! I am so super excited about this book, and have been seeing it all over the place! Please do enter me in your awesome giveaway!!
ReplyDeletezibilee(at)figearo(dot)net
Oh yes! Sign me up! Thanks for the great giveaway!
ReplyDeletetiger_fan_1997(at)yahoo(dot)com
Would love to be entered. Many thanks for the very informative post! :)
ReplyDeleterubs.escalona [at] gmail.com
I'd like to enter!
ReplyDeletestarmetaloak(at)gmail(dot)com
I have heard great things about this book.
ReplyDeleteamandarwest at gmaildotcom
Thanks for the giveaway!
ReplyDeleteRachelhwallen@gmail.com
OOHH!! Pick me, pick me! I would love to read this.
ReplyDeleteLaura
laura.leahj@gmail.com
This is one of those books I've been looking forward to for several weeks already. :)
ReplyDeletesrfbluemama[at]gmail[dot]com
I would love to win a copy of this one Amy!
ReplyDeletejoannelong74 AT gmail DOT com
I've been excited about this book! Would love to enter.
ReplyDeleteLisa.2713 at gmail dot com
Great post, great sounding book. I'm always amazed by how much further advanced the Moors seemed to be - more tolerant, more forward thinking, actually more 'civilized'. Thanks for the great giveaway.
ReplyDeletelcbrower40(at)gmail(dot)com
This one sounds so interesting.
ReplyDeleteplease enter me.
thank you
kaiminani at gmail dot com
First of all, don't enter me -- have it and am starting it today! The timeline is very interesting... notice the exact year Normandy conquered England there was strife in Spain... that is also a year of Halley's comet which so many people thought auspicious. There are so many words I'm not familiar with. Must start reading!
ReplyDeleteI would love to win this book. I would to learn more about Spain at this time seeing how much I have read about England, Wales, and Scotland.
ReplyDeleteThank you for the chance to win
Gail Miller
rosepedal60@gmail.com
Very interesting note on Halley's Comet...so much to remember and so much to learn. Who needs drama when we have history to entertain us! Great post and sounds like an intense read. Thanks Amy for hosting another great read.
ReplyDeleteRoberta
rlphilbr13@aol.com
This book's on my wishlist! I'd love to win one! JDQ1175@aol.com
ReplyDeleteThank you for entering me. =)
ReplyDeletetiredwkids at live dot com
This sounds loke a great giveaway,
ReplyDeleteplease enter me!
CarolNWong@aol.com
Sounds like a wonderful book. Please enter me and thank you for the giveaway.
ReplyDeletedebraldufek AT hotmail DOT com
Would love to win this one!
ReplyDeleteHPelkey1982@yahoo.com
this looks awesome thanks for the giveaway minsthins at optonline dot net
ReplyDeleteI would like to be entered, sounds like an interesting book!
ReplyDeletedelilah0180(at)yahoo(dot)com
I have read other guest post by Mitchell, and each one I read is very interesting. I am learning many new things which is making my interest in the book grow. I love historical fiction, and one of the things that I love most is the effort, and time authors must put into *knowing* their historical information. In other words, the research needed for good historical novels is incredibly impressive.
ReplyDeleteI would love to win this book!
ibeeeg(at)gmail(dot)com
This is a fabulous post, and what a great chance to win this book! Thanks.
ReplyDelete~Bella
Nunezbella at hotmail dotcom
Very interesting post! History is so fascinating to me. Would love to read this book. Thanks for the chance!
ReplyDeletemiller4plusmore(at)bellsouth(dot)net
Sounds like an awesome book. Please enter me for it!!
ReplyDeleteI follow on gfc
mlawson17 at hotmail dot com
Thanks for the chance!
ReplyDeletesix_one_nine_girlie86 (at) yahoo (dot) com
The more I read about this book and the history behind it, the more I want to read it. So many truly horrific things have been done in the name of religion. Christianity is as guilt or guilty as any other. They destroyed a thriving culture in Spain and forced 2 vibrant peoples from the land. As with many other such actions, greed and power had more to do with it all than religion. Thank you for hosting the giveaway.
ReplyDeletelibrarypat AT comcast DOT net
yes please, I would love to read this book
ReplyDeleteadrianecoros(at)gmail.com
This is on my summer read list I would love to read this!
ReplyDeleteHave been seeing this book everywhere and would love to win! vvperesk@gmail.com
ReplyDeleteThis period in history is one of my favorites, and especially so when it deals with Spain. I recently read a novel by Phillippa Gregory about Catherine (Catalina) of Aragon and her parents, Isabella and Ferdinand. This would give me even more insight to their stories.
ReplyDeletePlease enter me in the contest. Would love to read this book.
Marilyn Celeste Morris
marilyncmorris@sbcglobal.net
Wow, this sounds like such a good book. Please enter me in the giveaway!
ReplyDeleteThanks,
candc320@gmail.com
Thanks for this wonderful giveaway. saubleb(at)gmail(dot)com
ReplyDeleteNo need to enter me.
ReplyDeleteWhat an amazing timeline! I never realized Spain went through so many changes throughout it's history. We always read about England and France, but never Spain, which is odd since it was one of the big three back then.
Great informative post.
I would love to enter!
ReplyDeletechoateorama(at)gmail(dot)com
please count me in...thanks :)
ReplyDeletekarenk
kmkuka at yahoo dot com
I love the time period. This sounds like a fantastic book. Thanks for the chance
ReplyDeletejason(at)allworldautomotive(dot)com
What a great post! Now I really want to win this!
ReplyDeletemadamerkf at aol dot com
Sounds like a great book. Thanks for the giveaway.
ReplyDeleteeswright18 at gmail dot com
This looks fascinating! Please enter me!
ReplyDeletebethsbookreviewblog2 AT gmail DOT com
Wonderful post! I'd love to read more - thanks for the chance to win a copy!
ReplyDeletegeebee.reads AT gmail DOT com
As a history teacher I know the basics of the convivencia, but reading about it through a fictionalized point of view makes it all so much more real! I'd love to win!
ReplyDeleteOooo, please enter me for this! I'd love to read it.
ReplyDeleteMarie
utah91960[at]yahoo[dot]com
This is a very nicely written post. I would love to read this book. Please enter me for this giveaway.
ReplyDeletearchanaskorner(at)gmail(dot)com
I don't think I have ever had the urge to read a book about Columbus, until now. Thanks for the opportunity!
ReplyDeletelovejessicamarie (@) gmail (.) com
ps. you probably don't remember me, but I just wanted to say hello! I am trying to get back into the swing of blogging ;) and have missed your blog dearly!
This sounds like a fascinating read. Please enter me in the giveaway. Thank you!
ReplyDeletecrittercrazyjen(at)gmail(dot)com
Hearing great things about this one! Please count me in. Thank you!
ReplyDeletenfmgirl AT gmail DOT com
I'd love to enter Amy. Thanks.
ReplyDeletebj19662001 (at) yahoo (dot) ca
This book sounds very interesting, and I would love to read it. Please enter me. Thanks!
ReplyDeleteayancey(at)dishmail(dot)net
The cover is really quite beautiful, isn't it? :)
ReplyDeleteLaina1312@gmail.com
Hey there,
ReplyDeleteUseful info if one is interested in writing a historical. Me I just love reading them and sometimes an author will throw a shapeshifter into the mix and I really like that. Congrats on the latest release.
Robin
Robbibird3@aol.com
Sounds fascinating! I'm currently studying Juana's story, so this would be a great follow up! Thank you for having this contest and for writing about such a unique and interesting story!
ReplyDeleteLynne
aaffstew@aol.com
thanks for the chance to win!
ReplyDeletemannasweeps (at) gmail DOT com
I find the cover especially intriguing. Please enter me in the giveaway.
ReplyDeletewolfcarol451(at)gmail(dot)com
This sounds like a delightful book, thank you for allowing me the chance to win a copy.
ReplyDeleteknittingmomof3 (AT) gmail (DOT) com
SOunds great! Hope I;m not too ate for the giveaway
ReplyDeletedftrew(At)gmail(dot)Com